Whether the Article 4 direction reaches your outbuilding
This is the check that most affects the convert-or-build decision on a designated Stanmore address, and it is one people rarely make. Article 4 directions vary in scope, and Harrow’s were made conservation area by conservation area over a period of years with different content. Some address only front elevations and street-facing changes — replacement windows, doors, roof coverings, boundary treatments visible from the road — leaving the permitted development rights for outbuildings in rear gardens intact. Others reach further and withdraw rights for outbuildings as well, on the reasoning that a garden building can be visible in views across an estate or affect the setting of a group of houses. Where the direction does reach outbuildings, a new garden room needs a planning application, which changes the cost and programme comparison against converting the existing garage significantly. Where it does not, the outbuilding may still fall within permitted development subject to the usual limits on height, position relative to boundaries and the proportion of garden covered. There is no way to know which without obtaining the specific direction for the specific conservation area and reading it. We do that at the route review stage precisely because it determines which of the two projects is worth developing, and it is a much cheaper way to find out than designing the wrong one.